Guess pass

[swellvermin]

Play Pass is worse than Play Run imo. At least if they guess run they are leaving themselves open to get absolutely torched by the passing game. There is no downside at all to guessing pass however. The defenders mirror all the routes perfectly on pass plays and yet still play the run like the 85 Bears. You can't see it because its not as obvious as the all out blitz of guess run but its a lot more overpowering because its all reward with no risk.

+1 GAF

[nightwing_v6]

Play Pass is worse than Play Run imo. At least if they guess run they are leaving themselves open to get absolutely torched by the passing game. There is no downside at all to guessing pass however. The defenders mirror all the routes perfectly on pass plays and yet still play the run like the 85 Bears. You can't see it because its not as obvious as the all out blitz of guess run but its a lot more overpowering because its all reward with no risk.

Thank you

[trendon]

I guarantee I know EXACTLY how Doctor, Razorback, and swell play. I can see it now playing out in my head.

[shel311]

I guarantee I know EXACTLY how Doctor, Razorback, and swell play. I can see it now playing out in my head.

DIAF MIDDLE PASS!!!

[ajalves]

I guarantee I know EXACTLY how Doctor, Razorback, and swell play. I can see it now playing out in my head.

they are 100% correct. There is no downside to the feature (play the pass, and quite honestly play the run as well most times).

[trendon]

I guarantee I know EXACTLY how Doctor, Razorback, and swell play. I can see it now playing out in my head.

they are 100% correct. There is no downside to the feature (play the pass, and quite honestly play the run as well most times).

Then let's ratify a rule change that GUESS RUN is now allowed. I should be allowed to go for it on 4th-and-30 from my own 1 on the opening possession. This is football, not LittleBigPlanet. I still think our rulebook should look like this:

1. Don't cheat.
2. Don't beat someone by more than 35.
3. That's it.

We have these coaches reports! Let's let them do their job.

[ajalves]

1. Don't cheat.
2. Don't beat someone by more than 35.
3. That's it.

lets start a 120 person league, let you run it and see if you can make it through a season.

furthermore, how do those rules even make sense?

Dont cheat? what exacty doe sthat mean? whats cheating?

Dont beat someone by more than 35? why would you make this a rule when you have said you are against it?

the guess run and guess pass and things like that are game flaws. the way you talk about these things are as if they work properly. they dont. many people would probably be fine with whatever if it worked right.

[trendon]

the guess run and guess pass and things like that are game flaws.

LOL.

You guys win. Don't think, people, it is bad for you! My apologies. I should have stayed out like I promised the first time.

[ajalves]

the guess run and guess pass and things like that are game flaws.

LOL.

You guys win. Don't think, people, it is bad for you! My apologies. I should have stayed out like I promised the first time.

you act like you've discovered the atom or something when you imply we should be "thinking" more in our gameplay. if you guess pass, then 9/10 times you should be susceptible to a 5-8 yards draw play....that doesnt EVER happen.

whats that got to do with thinking?

also, as usual, just ignore every other point made.

[trendon]

And you are! Guess pass makes it harder to stop the run. It doesn't change the behavior of the defensive line, though, and I don't trust anyone in this league to notice that; whether it be because of perception bias or stupidity.

What's funny is GUESS RUN has four outcomes, three of them being shitty. Yet that one is banned ... a kneejerk reaction because one or two guys didn't like it in the first week. Then we'll have people telling ME to "go lab." LOL! The league doesn't even do it, why should I?

[shel311]

What's funny is GUESS RUN has four outcomes, three of them being shitty. Yet that one is banned ... a kneejerk reaction because one or two guys didn't like it in the first week. Then we'll have people telling ME to "go lab." LOL! The league doesn't even do it, why should I?

You clearly don't remember when that feature first came out, no chance.

If I picked guess middle and you ran the ball, 90% of the time you were losing yards, don't care where that run was going, didn't matter.

[trendon]

What's funny is GUESS RUN has four outcomes, three of them being shitty. Yet that one is banned ... a kneejerk reaction because one or two guys didn't like it in the first week. Then we'll have people telling ME to "go lab." LOL! The league doesn't even do it, why should I?

You clearly don't remember when that feature first came out, no chance.

If I picked guess middle and you ran the ball, 90% of the time you were losing yards, don't care where that run was going, didn't matter.

Well, let's review it because I use it against my more friendly opponents when I am losing big and I know they won't care and it never works unless I guess specifically correctly.

[ajalves]

What's funny is GUESS RUN has four outcomes, three of them being shitty. Yet that one is banned ... a kneejerk reaction because one or two guys didn't like it in the first week. Then we'll have people telling ME to "go lab." LOL! The league doesn't even do it, why should I?

You clearly don't remember when that feature first came out, no chance.

If I picked guess middle and you ran the ball, 90% of the time you were losing yards, don't care where that run was going, didn't matter.

Well, let's review it because I use it against my more friendly opponents when I am losing big and I know they won't care and it never works unless I guess specifically correctly.

you're buffalo. Now lets make a rule that has to work for the league as a whole.

the only time it works for buffalo is when you guess the right direction, that isnt the case with 75% of the defenses. in that case it works like Shel mentioned. thus a rule must be made that is fair for everyone, not just trendon

[trendon]

Have we ever reviewed it though beyond NCAA 07?

[ajalves]

Have we ever reviewed it though beyond NCAA 07?

yes.

believe it or not we do actually do stuff behind the scenes to help keep the NDL train moving.

We dont ever ask for appreciation or attention, but that doesnt mean that there are 25% of the league working behind the scenes to keep things "good"

[brwnbear]

Have we ever reviewed it though beyond NCAA 07?

yes.

believe it or not we do actually do stuff behind the scenes to help keep the NDL train moving.

We dont ever ask for appreciation or attention, but that doesnt mean that there are 25% of the league working behind the scenes to keep things "good"

Trendon complaining to AJ about the league...

This seems too ironic to be random.

[trendon]

I WANT FOUR SEASONS! FOUR SEASONS A CALENDAR YEAR! ARRGH!

(I actually do especially since this last season went to shit for me.)

[ajalves]

Have we ever reviewed it though beyond NCAA 07?

yes.

believe it or not we do actually do stuff behind the scenes to help keep the NDL train moving.

We dont ever ask for appreciation or attention, but that doesnt mean that there are 25% of the league working behind the scenes to keep things "good"

Trendon complaining to AJ about the league...

This seems too ironic to be random.

I'm not even in charge anymore

[shel311]

I WANT FOUR SEASONS! FOUR SEASONS A CALENDAR YEAR! ARRGH!

ISWYDT

[jsence2]

I guarantee I know EXACTLY how Doctor, Razorback, and swell play. I can see it now playing out in my head.

they are 100% correct. There is no downside to the feature (play the pass, and quite honestly play the run as well most times).

Not true....run a draw play against Play the Pass, and I bet you go for 15-20 yds if you know how to run the ball behind your blockers.