Age limits in the Minors?

[ajalves]

Should we enforce age limits on minor league levels?

My thinking is that winning/losing both helps and hurts the development of guys. I could be wrong, just a theory i have always had

ie - i don't think we should have 26 and 27 year olds in AA. They are fully developed and pump up the record of the team and they crush 99% of 22 year olds.

Its early in the morning and maybe I am not fully explaining it

Just throwing this out there, although it might be WAY too much work to enforce

[Uuaww]

You can vote for both options. I don't really have an opinion on this one...

[Cnasty]

I could be wrong, just a theory i have always had

Not wrong and also read having top prospects on shitty teams also stunts growth as well.

Would be tough to manage though from Billy’s perspective but many random audits here and there.

[plasma1896]

I think cleaning up the minor leagues to the limits is the 1st step. imagine having to sort thru rhode island 138 man AAA team.

[wdoupis]

11 more votes here, please vote if you have not and get this wrapped up

[Cnasty]

This is so stupid lol

[GeorgesGoons]

This is so stupid lol

as is the not voting for realignment, especially if you want to stay where you are you can

[Cnasty]

bump

[shel311]

What are we supposed to do with the bump?

Reminisce on that time the vote didn't pass?

[Cnasty]

Since its been such a hot topic it was fun to re-explore how badly it didnt pass

[GeorgesGoons]

Does age really matter? If a guy is a 20/20 scrub it wouldn't matter if he was in AAA or A ball. Dude sucks either way. Maybe limit overall ratings, but you couldn't do that either as all of our scouts see everyone so differently.

[The_Niddler]

Cant limit ratings because per neurotic, it is better to have a team full of 20/20 players then to have ghost players.

[Cnasty]

Older dudes dominating our lower levels stunts prospect growth as our ratings/potentials are tied to ability/statistics.

If we consistently have our minors with dudes at 25-27 in short a or single a pummeling prospects you see gradual stunting of prospect growth.

I’ll see if I can find the forum post I read on it.

But then scouting is still broken so who cares and it may not matter anyways

[GeorgesGoons]

Older dudes dominating our lower levels stunts prospect growth as our ratings/potentials are tied to ability/statistics.

If we consistently have our minors with dudes at 25-27 in short a or single a pummeling prospects you see gradual stunting of prospect growth.

I’ll see if I can find the forum post I read on it.

But then scouting is still broken so who cares and it may not matter anyways

i never pay too much attention to who is in my minors except for the higher level prospects.

But noticed i had a 26 year old in A or AA ball Trust me, he is helping your guys growth.