I could not isolate overtime games, sadly.
1. New Mexico 73 Colorado State 70 (143) [Season 12]
Coaches: UKALLTHEWAY v. Whit
2. Nevada-Las Vegas 69 Brigham Young 66 (135) [Season 16]
Coaches: TEEwade v. TXHUSTLE
3. Houston 67 Baylor 65 (132) [Season 19]
Coaches: RanDawg v. TerpsMustDie
4. Mississippi State 65 Minnesota 59 [3 OT] (124) [Season 17]
Coaches: runthepound v. ChampDawg
5. Rutgers 61 Connecticut 58 [2 OT] (119) [Season 17]
Coaches: cameron99933 v. driccio21
6. Louisiana Tech 60 Louisiana-Lafayette 57 (117) [Season 7]
Coaches: Whit v. BsktbllJk
7t. Illinois 59 Penn State 57 (116) [Season 13]
Coaches: sdrawkcab v. ssi7698
7t. Minnesota 59 Iowa 57 (116) [Season 7]
Coaches: Syronedog v. bigred
9. Baylor 66 Middle Tennessee State 48 (114) [Season 16]
Coaches: usmarine7t v. LGF
10. Army 58 South Florida 55 (113) [Season 9]
Coaches: doc1424 v. Trendon
Highest Scoring Games of All-Time
Re: Highest Scoring Games of All-Time
You have the UNLV score wrong. #2 was UNLV 69 BYU 66.