NDL Forum

Nationals Send:
RF - J. Werth (84)
CP - R. Soriano (82)

Brewers Send:
RF - R. Braun (85)
CP - F. Rodriguez (79)

Initially, I do not see any issues.
I will have to look at the players ages and such, but you know the drill.

The_Niddler wrote:Initially, I do not see any issues.
I will have to look at the players ages and such, but you know the drill.

Ryan Braun is a MVP from like 2 yrs ago, is like 26 yrs old and a monster and Jayson Werth sucks. K well maybe doesnt suck but hes 35 and not on Braun level

nick wrote:

The_Niddler wrote:Initially, I do not see any issues.
I will have to look at the players ages and such, but you know the drill.

Ryan Braun is a MVP from like 2 yrs ago, is like 26 yrs old and a monster and Jayson Werth sucks. K well maybe doesnt suck but hes 35 and not on Braun level

That's what my first thought was.

1 year league. Sure.

Dynasty league. Hell no

BFiVL wrote:1 year league. Sure.

Dynasty league. Hell no

But if the criteria is "well, would the team make this deal in real life?" for one trade, it has to go for all trades. Thus, it's a discussion.

Just to throw it out there, I submitted the trade solely based on this being a 1yr league, per Ryan. Obviously I wouldn't submit that if it were a multi-year league.

nick wrote:

The_Niddler wrote:Initially, I do not see any issues.
I will have to look at the players ages and such, but you know the drill.

Ryan Braun is a MVP from like 2 yrs ago, is like 26 yrs old and a monster and Jayson Werth sucks. K well maybe doesnt suck but hes 35 and not on Braun level

We dont need you 2 cents in here.

ANd thats funny cause I was actually looking at Braun also this AM. But I was giving up Joey Bats.

But yea Werth is kinda MEH compaired to Braun.

So can Ryan weigh in on all of this?

I am hearing it is a 1 year league just in the sense that owners want to move around.
But he has not told us if he will reset after each season or what will happen.

I think stuff like that should have been discussed before we let anyone make trades.
Not that this one is the issue. Just saying in general.

I need to understand how I should be looking at all of this when I am trying to evaluate trades.

I_S33M_THAB33T_U wrote:

nick wrote:

The_Niddler wrote:Initially, I do not see any issues.
I will have to look at the players ages and such, but you know the drill.

Ryan Braun is a MVP from like 2 yrs ago, is like 26 yrs old and a monster and Jayson Werth sucks. K well maybe doesnt suck but hes 35 and not on Braun level

We dont need you 2 cents in here.

ANd thats funny cause I was actually looking at Braun also this AM. But I was giving up Joey Bats.

But yea Werth is kinda MEH compaired to Braun.

Again this is for us to discuss the trades Nick, not for you to come in and be your usual DOUCHE self.


@ Niddler - It is done after 1 season, I have said this more then enough. It will be deleted after seasons end.

My vote then is for the trade.
It is an even trade.

Still kinda on the edge on this one.

Braun is there SUPERSTAR.

Werth is not even close. ANd I feel that Soriano was just thrown in there to offset this.

I think you guys are putting too much thought into this, if it's just a 1yr league.

It's a 1pt increase in the starting RF position for my team and 3pt increase in the Closer position for their team. That is literally all of the thought I put into it, other than I don't like Werth standing at the plate and I do like Ryan Braun as a player, mostly because I've had the chance to chat with him a few times.

You can go either way, but let me know so I can go look for someone else to trade for if this one isn't going to go through.

ReignOnU wrote:I think you guys are putting too much thought into this, if it's just a 1yr league.

This was why I responded with, ok then, since 1 year, my vote is yes.
I am just looking at overall pretty much if it is going to get reset after every season.

Game processed it at 12:52.

SO i guess it went through.