NDL Forum

Hah we all have those guys. I released Tsukasa Ichikawa as he was like 37 potential. Edmonton signed him and he blew up lol.

Makes me look at every guy in my org though. And I always have (save for one year) and always will have max dev budget - scouting too.

shel311 wrote: ↑Fri Jul 09, 2021 1:53 pm

TheGobOne wrote: ↑Fri Jul 09, 2021 1:43 pm I believe I had him mid 50's when I traded

Same, 55 rated DH only when I traded him.

Seemed like the right play, as those types are dime a dozen, and I returned a 3 ish WAR 2B.


Welp, that didn't quite work out how I planned.

But that's ok, at least it's not like I traded a 27 potential Jose Rodriguez to Port Orange as a throw in only to have him go from 27 potential to 71 that offseason.

50 overall dh/1b are amazing. Reason they’re usually that low is cause they’re an abomination defensively.

nick wrote: ↑Fri Jul 09, 2021 3:13 pm 50 overall dh/1b are amazing. Reason they’re usually that low is cause they’re an abomination defensively.

They're also easy to find, generally speaking.

TheGobOne wrote: ↑Fri Jul 09, 2021 1:12 pm Ramos over Herrera? Wow.....that's a robbery right there IMO. A full time DH winning MVP, have we even seen that before?

Not sure if Nonaka was a DH or still 1B his last MVP. I know Fuji had to have been a DH during some of his MVPs with Ted

File is uploading...

Over here in Boston we’re making moves you guys better watch out

Still gets me that people will draft a guy out of Low A who’s like 23 OVR thinking they can stash him and not destroy his development.

A tale as old as time lol. We’ll see you on the retirement page in 4 seasons Mr Fox.

In case someone wants to see the Rule 5 log:

Houston Alcoholics: Drafted CF Martin Lyons in the 2082 Rule 5 Draft (Round 1, Pick 1, 1st overall Pick) from the Omaha Beef.
Burnaby Lakers: Lost RP Orlando Rodríguez in the Rule 5 Draft to the Los Angeles Bomb Squad.
Los Angeles Bomb Squad: Drafted RP Orlando Rodríguez in the 2082 Rule 5 Draft (Round 1, Pick 2, 2nd overall Pick) from the Burnaby Lakers.
Philadelphia Cheesesteaks: Lost SS José Vargas in the Rule 5 Draft to the San Diego Invaders.
San Diego Invaders: Drafted SS José Vargas in the 2082 Rule 5 Draft (Round 1, Pick 3, 3rd overall Pick) from the Philadelphia Cheesesteaks.
Port Orange Hawks: Lost 2B Mathew Baker in the Rule 5 Draft to the Burnaby Lakers.
Burnaby Lakers: Drafted 2B Mathew Baker in the 2082 Rule 5 Draft (Round 1, Pick 5, 5th overall Pick) from the Port Orange Hawks.
Alabama Bears: Lost SP Bill Young in the Rule 5 Draft to the New England Spitters.
New England Spitters: Drafted SP Bill Young in the 2082 Rule 5 Draft (Round 1, Pick 7, 7th overall Pick) from the Alabama Bears.
Baltimore Red Crabs: Lost SP Mark Baxter in the Rule 5 Draft to the Chicago Cossacks.
Chicago Cossacks: Drafted SP Mark Baxter in the 2082 Rule 5 Draft (Round 1, Pick 8, 8th overall Pick) from the Baltimore Red Crabs.
Omaha Beef: Lost SP Pedro Flores in the Rule 5 Draft to the Boston Spitfire.
Boston Spitfire: Drafted SP Pedro Flores in the 2082 Rule 5 Draft (Round 1, Pick 11, 11th overall Pick) from the Omaha Beef.
Alabama Bears: Lost LF Héctor Vargas in the Rule 5 Draft to the Ann Arbor Vipers.
Ann Arbor Vipers: Drafted LF Héctor Vargas in the 2082 Rule 5 Draft (Round 1, Pick 13, 13th overall Pick) from the Alabama Bears.
Baltimore Red Crabs: Lost RP Dave Gillespie in the Rule 5 Draft to the Alabama Bears.
Alabama Bears: Drafted RP Dave Gillespie in the 2082 Rule 5 Draft (Round 1, Pick 16, 16th overall Pick) from the Baltimore Red Crabs.
Miami Vice: Lost 2B Walton Burgess in the Rule 5 Draft to the Winterfell Direwolves.
Winterfell Direwolves: Drafted 2B Walton Burgess in the 2082 Rule 5 Draft (Round 1, Pick 17, 17th overall Pick) from the Miami Vice.
Edmonton Mounties: Lost RP Francisco Cisneros in the Rule 5 Draft to the Seattle Windstorm.
Seattle Windstorm: Drafted RP Francisco Cisneros in the 2082 Rule 5 Draft (Round 1, Pick 22, 22nd overall Pick) from the Edmonton Mounties.
Prosper Eagles: Lost RF Rusty Holloway in the Rule 5 Draft to the Baltimore Red Crabs.
Baltimore Red Crabs: Drafted RF Rusty Holloway in the 2082 Rule 5 Draft (Round 1, Pick 23, 23rd overall Pick) from the Prosper Eagles.
New England Spitters: Lost C Sadaharu Ishibashi in the Rule 5 Draft to the Cookeville Cubs.
Cookeville Cubs: Drafted C Sadaharu Ishibashi in the 2082 Rule 5 Draft (Round 1, Pick 27, 27th overall Pick) from the New England Spitters.
Baltimore Red Crabs: Lost 3B Liam Quiñones in the Rule 5 Draft to the Moose Jaw Diamond Dogs.
Moose Jaw Diamond Dogs: Drafted 3B Liam Quiñones in the 2082 Rule 5 Draft (Round 1, Pick 29, 29th overall Pick) from the Baltimore Red Crabs.
Shelby Smokies: Lost SP Ray Carlisle in the Rule 5 Draft to the Los Angeles Bomb Squad.
Los Angeles Bomb Squad: Drafted SP Ray Carlisle in the 2082 Rule 5 Draft (Round 2, Pick 2, 32nd overall Pick) from the Shelby Smokies.
Charleston Oysters: Lost CF Jesús Estrada in the Rule 5 Draft to the San Diego Invaders.
San Diego Invaders: Drafted CF Jesús Estrada in the 2082 Rule 5 Draft (Round 2, Pick 3, 33rd overall Pick) from the Charleston Oysters.
Rhode Island Red Wolves: Lost 1B Hayden Daniels in the Rule 5 Draft to the Burnaby Lakers.
Burnaby Lakers: Drafted 1B Hayden Daniels in the 2082 Rule 5 Draft (Round 2, Pick 5, 35th overall Pick) from the Rhode Island Red Wolves.
Omaha Beef: Lost 2B David Inman in the Rule 5 Draft to the New England Spitters.
New England Spitters: Drafted 2B David Inman in the 2082 Rule 5 Draft (Round 2, Pick 7, 37th overall Pick) from the Omaha Beef.
Seattle Windstorm: Lost SP Dan Blackshaw in the Rule 5 Draft to the Chicago Cossacks.
Chicago Cossacks: Drafted SP Dan Blackshaw in the 2082 Rule 5 Draft (Round 2, Pick 8, 38th overall Pick) from the Seattle Windstorm.
Baltimore Red Crabs: Lost CL Víctor Soto in the Rule 5 Draft to the Ann Arbor Vipers.
Ann Arbor Vipers: Drafted CL Víctor Soto in the 2082 Rule 5 Draft (Round 2, Pick 13, 43rd overall Pick) from the Baltimore Red Crabs.
Miami Vice: Lost RP Fernando Ibáñez in the Rule 5 Draft to the Seattle Windstorm.
Seattle Windstorm: Drafted RP Fernando Ibáñez in the 2082 Rule 5 Draft (Round 2, Pick 22, 52nd overall Pick) from the Miami Vice.
Rhode Island Red Wolves: Lost RF Chuck Turner in the Rule 5 Draft to the Baltimore Red Crabs.
Baltimore Red Crabs: Drafted RF Chuck Turner in the 2082 Rule 5 Draft (Round 2, Pick 23, 53rd overall Pick) from the Rhode Island Red Wolves.
Moose Jaw Diamond Dogs: Lost SS Jonathan Fox in the Rule 5 Draft to the Los Angeles Bomb Squad.
Los Angeles Bomb Squad: Drafted SS Jonathan Fox in the 2082 Rule 5 Draft (Round 3, Pick 2, 62nd overall Pick) from the Moose Jaw Diamond Dogs.
Bowie Bulldogs: Lost CF Adam Gray in the Rule 5 Draft to the San Diego Invaders.
San Diego Invaders: Drafted CF Adam Gray in the 2082 Rule 5 Draft (Round 3, Pick 3, 63rd overall Pick) from the Bowie Bulldogs.
Miami Vice: Lost LF Nathan Ford in the Rule 5 Draft to the New England Spitters.
New England Spitters: Drafted LF Nathan Ford in the 2082 Rule 5 Draft (Round 3, Pick 7, 67th overall Pick) from the Miami Vice.
Shelby Smokies: Lost CF Rafael García in the Rule 5 Draft to the Seattle Windstorm.
Seattle Windstorm: Drafted CF Rafael García in the 2082 Rule 5 Draft (Round 3, Pick 22, 82nd overall Pick) from the Shelby Smokies.
Philadelphia Cheesesteaks: Lost RF Luis Ramírez in the Rule 5 Draft to the San Diego Invaders.
San Diego Invaders: Drafted RF Luis Ramírez in the 2082 Rule 5 Draft (Round 4, Pick 3, 93rd overall Pick) from the Philadelphia Cheesesteaks.
Ann Arbor Vipers: Lost SP Pancho Ruíz in the Rule 5 Draft to the New England Spitters.
New England Spitters: Drafted SP Pancho Ruíz in the 2082 Rule 5 Draft (Round 4, Pick 7, 97th overall Pick) from the Ann Arbor Vipers.
San Antonio Slackers: Lost SP Andrés Moreno in the Rule 5 Draft to the San Diego Invaders.
San Diego Invaders: Drafted SP Andrés Moreno in the 2082 Rule 5 Draft (Round 5, Pick 3, 123rd overall Pick) from the San Antonio Slackers.
Detroit Muscle: Lost LF Sam Webber in the Rule 5 Draft to the New England Spitters.
New England Spitters: Drafted LF Sam Webber in the 2082 Rule 5 Draft (Round 5, Pick 7, 127th overall Pick) from the Detroit Muscle.
Baltimore Red Crabs: Lost SP Pat Scott in the Rule 5 Draft to the San Diego Invaders.
San Diego Invaders: Drafted SP Pat Scott in the 2082 Rule 5 Draft (Round 6, Pick 3, 153rd overall Pick) from the Baltimore Red Crabs.
Charleston Oysters: Lost SP Tim Thomas in the Rule 5 Draft to the New England Spitters.
New England Spitters: Drafted SP Tim Thomas in the 2082 Rule 5 Draft (Round 6, Pick 7, 157th overall Pick) from the Charleston Oysters.
Philadelphia Cheesesteaks: Lost SS Rodrigo Rosales in the Rule 5 Draft to the New England Spitters.
New England Spitters: Drafted SS Rodrigo Rosales in the 2082 Rule 5 Draft (Round 7, Pick 7, 187th overall Pick) from the Philadelphia Cheesesteaks.
Philadelphia Cheesesteaks: Lost SS Jaime García in the Rule 5 Draft to the New England Spitters.
New England Spitters: Drafted SS Jaime García in the 2082 Rule 5 Draft (Round 8, Pick 7, 217th overall Pick) from the Philadelphia Cheesesteaks.
Burnaby Lakers: Lost RP Eric Swanson in the Rule 5 Draft to the New England Spitters.
New England Spitters: Drafted RP Eric Swanson in the 2082 Rule 5 Draft (Round 9, Pick 7, 247th overall Pick) from the Burnaby Lakers.
Ann Arbor Vipers: Lost SP Wade Decos in the Rule 5 Draft to the New England Spitters.
New England Spitters: Drafted SP Wade Decos in the 2082 Rule 5 Draft (Round 10, Pick 7, 277th overall Pick) from the Ann Arbor Vipers.

New England wont trade with me but theyll gladly just steal them. smh.

shel311 wrote: ↑Tue Sep 08, 2020 4:44 pm

DRWebs wrote: ↑Tue Sep 08, 2020 4:42 pm it really shouldn't generate this much debate

10 guys drafted in Rule 5 will always draw interest and posts

Just like every other instance in the past its a burning at the stake until its one of the good ole boys doing it

Questioning where an elite team will put those 10 guys equals a "burning at the stake"


I'll keep you in my prayers during these tough times.

A Wild Webby appears! Dude please take one of the open teams and show these fools how it's done.

File is uploading...

I've had a couple people ask me. No, Qaz is not back. Doc decided to move Fresno to Steel City.

Bill Quinn was a real one... salute

I used to be one of those voters who’d just put 4 guys on my list. Now I’ll put 10 even if they’re not deserving to give them another chance.

Nick believes in participation trophies, who knew?