NDL Forum

shel311 wrote:

Seeitsaveit13 wrote: Yes, but he also would have played dumb and said that he didn't steal the wallet, and offer to help figure out who did, after offering an alibi for how he couldn't have possibly stolen the wallet

All true, but he would have done all that while still holding on to the wallet.

shel311 wrote:Man, 2010-2025 was like the wild wild west of NDL OOTP.

Seeitsaveit13 wrote:I think Corey actually made the first ever reference of "crystal ball" on page 68 or so.

nick wrote:cant wait to commish and rig the leaguerun a solid organization

Cnasty wrote:

nick wrote:cant wait to commish and rig the leaguerun a solid organization

I had my own winter topic for this.

Replace Boston with a new guy and I'll commish full time.

It will probably be treated like one of Teds or George's poll though.

Cnasty wrote:

nick wrote:cant wait to commish and rig the leaguerun a solid organization

I had my own winter topic for this.

Replace Boston with a new guy and I'll commish full time.

It will probably be treated like one of Teds or George's poll though.

DRiccio21 wrote:

Cnasty wrote:But also missing from daves preamble was the experience, knowledge and naivety that most of us had to the situation and what some former members became.

Access to new information was received, reign supplied some stance on it with his experience, and my view changed completely.

So yes I may have been in the no retire camp early but also didn't have access to knowing as much as we fully did later on.

Fair to both arguments if you will.

i'm fairly certain we all knew he was tainted his whole career. I used to openly make jokes about it when he was on my team. guys sniffed out his lack of history and his ratings jumps pretty early on in his career. I still to this day don't know 'how' he was tainted (i know it was explained somewhere but i couldn't find it and don't remember) but we all knew and talked about him being 'off'.

I can't find the posts when we discussed retiring him, it must have been In the admin or in PM's.

but I did find a couple things:
- people weren't even sure if he was good anymore when Iseem traded for him and after a couple of his injuries guys were saying he was done
- corey listed him first as a first ballot hof in an old hall of fame thread (bring old corey back!)

I've always had the same thoughts. we knew he was tainted, he played tainted and if we allowed him to play we should be voting on him objectively like we are supposed to be voting on everyone who is eligible.

shel311 wrote:Man, 2010-2025 was like the wild wild west of NDL OOTP.

ajalves wrote: I don't have to vote on him like everyone else though. One doesn't have to go with the other

shel311 wrote:

ajalves wrote: I don't have to vote on him like everyone else though. One doesn't have to go with the other

Thanks Niddler.

shel311 wrote:

nick wrote:I was first. and second cause i wrote the same msg twice, but thats not the pont.

This is good reading.

http://onlinedynasty.net/forum/viewtopi ... as#p416378

ajalves wrote: Let him play, fine. I don't have to vote on him like everyone else who is eligible though. One doesn't have to go with the other.

DRiccio21 wrote:

ajalves wrote: Let him play, fine. I don't have to vote on him like everyone else who is eligible though. One doesn't have to go with the other.

fair, i have no problem with that rationalization