NDL Forum

Phelps
Thomas
Bryan
Cole
Crow
Gibbons
Hayden
P. Lopez
Peterson
Wu

ajalves wrote:

DRiccio21 wrote:

ajalves wrote:

shel311 wrote:The lack of respect for Wu is appaling!!!

Bo Jackson is no hall of famer

Bo couldn't have held Wu's jock strap.

in football

He played 4 years and while he obviously was awesome, he basically had less career yards and TDs than a good back gets in a 2 year span. Big difference from Wu.

shel311 wrote:

ajalves wrote:

DRiccio21 wrote:

ajalves wrote:

shel311 wrote:The lack of respect for Wu is appaling!!!

Bo Jackson is no hall of famer

Bo couldn't have held Wu's jock strap.

in football

He played 4 years and while he obviously was awesome, he basically had less career yards and TDs than a good back gets in a 2 year span. Big difference from Wu.

not in my mind. 5.5 ypc or something like that. apples n oranges maybe....

just stating my opinion. For ME, a bit of longevity is as important as a great 6 year run

Odds that Ramirez gets 1 vote?

Seeitsaveit13 wrote:Odds that Ramirez gets 1 vote?

at least 1 vote? or just 1 vote overall?

He's already got 1 vote, publicly.

Seeitsaveit13 wrote:Odds that Ramirez gets 1 vote?

Same as the odds that I vote

Whittness10 wrote:

Seeitsaveit13 wrote:Odds that Ramirez gets 1 vote?

at least 1 vote? or just 1 vote overall?

He's already got 1 vote, publicly.

Sorry, 2 votes. Didn't think anyone but Shel would vote for him...

shel311 wrote:

Seeitsaveit13 wrote:Odds that Ramirez gets 1 vote?

Same as the odds that I vote

You're arguing about Bo Jackson and making fun of JD for DrivewayGate.


Use that time to vote.

ajalves wrote: just stating my opinion. For ME, a bit of longevity is as important as a great 6 year run

it's a fair point.

something i didn't really think about, either.

i looked up the hall of fame registry and there really aren't any guys in it with that few of AB's in the ML (outside of a few guys from negro leagues and guys who played 120 years ago).

with that said, he played basically 8 full seasons. 7 of them were extremely high production. i'll take out one of the years he didn't play full amount of games and say he had 6 seasons with 1.000 + ops. there were only 13 players in MLB history who had that type of production.

Ruth, Bonds, Williams, Gehrig, Foxx, Pujols, Ramirez, Hornsby, Musial, Cobb, Thomas, Ott, Mantle is the list ending at guys who had at least 7.

Ed Delahanty (late 1800's), ARod, Greenberg have 6 seasons

now WITH that said, Todd Helton had 5 seasons with 1.000+ OPS and probably won't make the hall of fame.

DRiccio21 wrote: i'll take out one of the years he didn't play full amount of games and say he had 6 seasons with 1.000 + ops. there were only 13 players in MLB history who had that type of production.

Ruth, Bonds, Williams, Gehrig, Foxx, Pujols, Ramirez, Hornsby, Musial, Cobb, Thomas, Ott, Mantle is the list ending at guys who had at least 7.

Lock it up, get Wu in!!!

shel311 wrote:

DRiccio21 wrote: i'll take out one of the years he didn't play full amount of games and say he had 6 seasons with 1.000 + ops. there were only 13 players in MLB history who had that type of production.

Ruth, Bonds, Williams, Gehrig, Foxx, Pujols, Ramirez, Hornsby, Musial, Cobb, Thomas, Ott, Mantle is the list ending at guys who had at least 7.

Lock it up, get Wu in!!!

Maybe you should vote for him... now... while we're waiting on DrivewayGate...

Voted So Far (12)

San Antonio
New England
Port Orange
Boston
Miami
Washington
Toronto
Cleveland
Houston
Omaha
Philadelphia
Winterfell

I should have mine in tonight. Great work Bernie.

Ditto. Mine will be in this afternoon.

Xian-gan Xin
Duncan Phelps
Roger Peterson
Bill O'Higgins
Pablo Lopez
Jose Lopez
Jordan Hayden
Lawrence Franks

K. Thomas
Jim Cole
Marty Crow
Nolan Gibbons
Jordan Hayden
Pablo Lopez
Roger Peterson
P. Bourassa

Voted So Far (17)

San Antonio
New England
Port Orange
Boston
Miami
Washington
Toronto
Cleveland
Houston
Omaha
Philadelphia
Winterfell
Indianapolis
Steel City
Las Vegas
Cookeville
Albany

Waiting On (13)

Long Beach
Alabama
Chicago
Sheltown
Vancouver
New York
Detroit
Cincinnati
Texas
Dade County
Lake Elsinore
South Park
Hillsboro

Jim Cole
Marty Crow
Nolan Gibbons
Jordan Hayden
Pablo Lopez
Roger Peterson
P. Bourassa
Jose Lopez

O'Higgins
Thomas
Cole
J. Lopez
Burgos
Hayden
Peterson
Xin

Long Beach Ballot:

Marty Crow
Bill O'Higgins
Pablo Lopez
Kevin Thomas
Nolan Gibbons
Jim Cole
Zheng-Xin Wu
Jose Lopez