Trade Thread

Moderator: I_S33M_THAB33T_U

User avatar
ReignOnU
Reactions:
Posts: 19643
Joined: Sat Feb 07, 2009 12:18 pm
Location: Cincinnati Titans
Contact:

Re: Trade Thread

Post by ReignOnU »

We tinkered with the voting system in Niddler's league... it's a mess, bad idea. :-)
PSN: ReignOnU
The_Niddler
Reactions:
Posts: 17229
Joined: Thu Jan 21, 2010 6:57 pm
Location: Small Town, Ohio

Re: Trade Thread

Post by The_Niddler »

Yeah, the voting was ok, but I like this idea better personally.

And ryan just confirmed that he is allowing unlimited human-human trades until the trade deadline, but they still go through the trade committee obviously.
PSN: The_Niddler
TWITCH: The_Niddler
User avatar
jsence2
Reactions:
Posts: 18758
Joined: Tue Dec 16, 2008 10:57 pm
Location: Louisville, KY

Re: Trade Thread

Post by jsence2 »

Braves send:

SP Jose Fernandez (95 ovr, 21 years old, A potential)
2B Howie Kendrick (83 ovr, 30 years old, B potential)
CP Aaron Loup (79 ovr, 26 years old, C potential)

Padres send:

3B Evan Longira (92 ovr, 28 years old, A potential)
CP Kenley Jansen (90 ovr, 26 years old, A potential)
SP Matt Moore (84 ovr, 24 years old, B potential)

Note: Padres have Omar Infante who plays about 8 positions (including 3B) so the mismatch of positions won't be a problem. Also, the game showed "equal value" on this deal even without me adding Loup, and almost fair just for their three for Fernandez.
Image

S14: N Texas 7-1
S15: Wake 8-5
S16-21: Washington 9-4, 10-3, 8-5, 9-4, 7-6, 6-7
S22: Ohio 8-5
S23: ECU 12-2
S24-26: Kentucky 8-5, 5-7, 5-7
Career: 102-61
User avatar
I_S33M_THAB33T_U
Reactions:
Posts: 4848
Joined: Tue Sep 15, 2009 1:28 am
Contact:

Re: Trade Thread

Post by I_S33M_THAB33T_U »

jsence2 wrote:Braves send:

SP Jose Fernandez (95 ovr, 21 years old, A potential)
2B Howie Kendrick (83 ovr, 30 years old, B potential)
CP Aaron Loup (79 ovr, 26 years old, C potential)

Padres send:

3B Evan Longira (92 ovr, 28 years old, A potential)
CP Kenley Jansen (90 ovr, 26 years old, A potential)
SP Matt Moore (84 ovr, 24 years old, B potential)

Note: Padres have Omar Infante who plays about 8 positions (including 3B) so the mismatch of positions won't be a problem. Also, the game showed "equal value" on this deal even without me adding Loup, and almost fair just for their three for Fernandez.
I am going to say NO.

You are only giving them Fernandez in return for 3 players that are better then the 2 you are giving up. All of which are 28 or younger. The Padres gain nothing in this deal in my eyes. They lose all the way around.
User avatar
jsence2
Reactions:
Posts: 18758
Joined: Tue Dec 16, 2008 10:57 pm
Location: Louisville, KY

Re: Trade Thread

Post by jsence2 »

I_S33M_THAB33T_U wrote:
jsence2 wrote:Braves send:

SP Jose Fernandez (95 ovr, 21 years old, A potential)
2B Howie Kendrick (83 ovr, 30 years old, B potential)
CP Aaron Loup (79 ovr, 26 years old, C potential)

Padres send:

3B Evan Longira (92 ovr, 28 years old, A potential)
CP Kenley Jansen (90 ovr, 26 years old, A potential)
SP Matt Moore (84 ovr, 24 years old, B potential)

Note: Padres have Omar Infante who plays about 8 positions (including 3B) so the mismatch of positions won't be a problem. Also, the game showed "equal value" on this deal even without me adding Loup, and almost fair just for their three for Fernandez.
I am going to say NO.

You are only giving them Fernandez in return for 3 players that are better then the 2 you are giving up. All of which are 28 or younger. The Padres gain nothing in this deal in my eyes. They lose all the way around.

Yep, because getting an SP who is miles better than any they have is nothing.
Image

S14: N Texas 7-1
S15: Wake 8-5
S16-21: Washington 9-4, 10-3, 8-5, 9-4, 7-6, 6-7
S22: Ohio 8-5
S23: ECU 12-2
S24-26: Kentucky 8-5, 5-7, 5-7
Career: 102-61
The_Niddler
Reactions:
Posts: 17229
Joined: Thu Jan 21, 2010 6:57 pm
Location: Small Town, Ohio

Re: Trade Thread

Post by The_Niddler »

jsence2 wrote:Braves send:

SP Jose Fernandez (95 ovr, 21 years old, A potential)
2B Howie Kendrick (83 ovr, 30 years old, B potential)
CP Aaron Loup (79 ovr, 26 years old, C potential)

Padres send:

3B Evan Longira (92 ovr, 28 years old, A potential)
CP Kenley Jansen (90 ovr, 26 years old, A potential)
SP Matt Moore (84 ovr, 24 years old, B potential)

Note: Padres have Omar Infante who plays about 8 positions (including 3B) so the mismatch of positions won't be a problem. Also, the game showed "equal value" on this deal even without me adding Loup, and almost fair just for their three for Fernandez.
I am going to say no.
And I am not saying you are not giving them nothing.

But when I look at it, I see:
You are giving up a 95 for a 92
Then an 83 for a 90
Then a 79 for an 84.

You have to look at the impact to their team.
They are going from a 90 to a 79 CP.
They are gaining a great SP, but losing 1 hell of a 3B.

You are taking their top 2 players in Longoria and Jensen.
Their next best 3B is a 71.

I understand you are giving up SP Fernandez, I understand you are willing to bet anything that he will become a 99 OVR.
You can make any argument you want, but nothing will change my mind. Sorry.
I feel the impact to them is too great.
PSN: The_Niddler
TWITCH: The_Niddler
User avatar
jsence2
Reactions:
Posts: 18758
Joined: Tue Dec 16, 2008 10:57 pm
Location: Louisville, KY

Re: Trade Thread

Post by jsence2 »

The_Niddler wrote:
jsence2 wrote:Braves send:

SP Jose Fernandez (95 ovr, 21 years old, A potential)
2B Howie Kendrick (83 ovr, 30 years old, B potential)
CP Aaron Loup (79 ovr, 26 years old, C potential)

Padres send:

3B Evan Longira (92 ovr, 28 years old, A potential)
CP Kenley Jansen (90 ovr, 26 years old, A potential)
SP Matt Moore (84 ovr, 24 years old, B potential)

Note: Padres have Omar Infante who plays about 8 positions (including 3B) so the mismatch of positions won't be a problem. Also, the game showed "equal value" on this deal even without me adding Loup, and almost fair just for their three for Fernandez.
I am going to say no.
And I am not saying you are not giving them nothing.

But when I look at it, I see:
You are giving up a 95 for a 92
Then an 83 for a 90
Then a 79 for an 84.

You have to look at the impact to their team.
They are going from a 90 to a 79 CP.
They are gaining a great SP, but losing 1 hell of a 3B.

You are taking their top 2 players in Longoria and Jensen.
Their next best 3B is a 71.

I understand you are giving up SP Fernandez, I understand you are willing to bet anything that he will become a 99 OVR.
You can make any argument you want, but nothing will change my mind. Sorry.
I feel the impact to them is too great.

Omar Infante is an 82 overall, and plays 3B. He moves to 3B, Kendrick plays 2B. I mentioned that in the initial post.
Image

S14: N Texas 7-1
S15: Wake 8-5
S16-21: Washington 9-4, 10-3, 8-5, 9-4, 7-6, 6-7
S22: Ohio 8-5
S23: ECU 12-2
S24-26: Kentucky 8-5, 5-7, 5-7
Career: 102-61
User avatar
ReignOnU
Reactions:
Posts: 19643
Joined: Sat Feb 07, 2009 12:18 pm
Location: Cincinnati Titans
Contact:

Re: Trade Thread

Post by ReignOnU »

jsence2 wrote:Braves send:

SP Jose Fernandez (95 ovr, 21 years old, A potential)
2B Howie Kendrick (83 ovr, 30 years old, B potential)
CP Aaron Loup (79 ovr, 26 years old, C potential)

Padres send:

3B Evan Longira (92 ovr, 28 years old, A potential)
CP Kenley Jansen (90 ovr, 26 years old, A potential)
SP Matt Moore (84 ovr, 24 years old, B potential)

Note: Padres have Omar Infante who plays about 8 positions (including 3B) so the mismatch of positions won't be a problem. Also, the game showed "equal value" on this deal even without me adding Loup, and almost fair just for their three for Fernandez.
I'm also going to vote no. While I weigh a great SP higher than a great hitter, it's not that significant of a difference. The Padres are already very depleted in terms of hitting, as Longoria is their only real offensive power. (Konerko is 37 now) Moore, while a big OVR difference from Fernandez, is currently their #2 SP and with any progression, will be their #1 SP next year. So they are really only getting an upgrade at the #1 SP spot, while taking massive hits at 3B and CP.

Just throwing it out there, so you can see my thoughts, but what I would consider fair would be something like Fernandez-Kendrick for Longoria-Moore. I still don't think it would be a smart move for SD, but I think from a talent/age perspective, that's a fair deal. Fernandez-Loup for Longoria-Jansen is probably pushing it and would take a lot of consideration.

Obviously some of these CPU teams suffer from how they drafted... some were just horrible. But there's always the perspective that Longoria was selected before Fernandez. Personally I don't think that matters, due to the CPU AI, but there's that also.
PSN: ReignOnU
User avatar
I_S33M_THAB33T_U
Reactions:
Posts: 4848
Joined: Tue Sep 15, 2009 1:28 am
Contact:

Re: Trade Thread

Post by I_S33M_THAB33T_U »

ReignOnU wrote:
jsence2 wrote:Braves send:

SP Jose Fernandez (95 ovr, 21 years old, A potential)
2B Howie Kendrick (83 ovr, 30 years old, B potential)
CP Aaron Loup (79 ovr, 26 years old, C potential)

Padres send:

3B Evan Longira (92 ovr, 28 years old, A potential)
CP Kenley Jansen (90 ovr, 26 years old, A potential)
SP Matt Moore (84 ovr, 24 years old, B potential)

Note: Padres have Omar Infante who plays about 8 positions (including 3B) so the mismatch of positions won't be a problem. Also, the game showed "equal value" on this deal even without me adding Loup, and almost fair just for their three for Fernandez.
I'm also going to vote no. While I weigh a great SP higher than a great hitter, it's not that significant of a difference. The Padres are already very depleted in terms of hitting, as Longoria is their only real offensive power. (Konerko is 37 now) Moore, while a big OVR difference from Fernandez, is currently their #2 SP and with any progression, will be their #1 SP next year. So they are really only getting an upgrade at the #1 SP spot, while taking massive hits at 3B and CP.

Just throwing it out there, so you can see my thoughts, but what I would consider fair would be something like Fernandez-Kendrick for Longoria-Moore. I still don't think it would be a smart move for SD, but I think from a talent/age perspective, that's a fair deal. Fernandez-Loup for Longoria-Jansen is probably pushing it and would take a lot of consideration.

Obviously some of these CPU teams suffer from how they drafted... some were just horrible. But there's always the perspective that Longoria was selected before Fernandez. Personally I don't think that matters, due to the CPU AI, but there's that also.

I agree in most part here.

Fernandez/Kendrick for Longoria/Moore would work. Still not great move for SD, but more in line with a fair deal.

Although, I don't agree with you on the Fernandez/Luop for Longoria/Jansen, Still to far apart. As Jenson is a 90 and Loup is a 79. Fernandez at 95 does not make up for the 11 point difference and the fact that Longoria was drafted ahead of Fernandez. Longoria is there only true hitter, and may be there best fielder as well. Infante/? is a downgrade to Longoria/Infante in my eyes.
User avatar
shel311
NDL Championships
NDL Championships
Reactions:
Posts: 72598
Joined: Sat Aug 30, 2008 11:51 pm
Location: Sheltown Shockers

Re: Trade Thread

Post by shel311 »

I wouldn't trade Jose Fernandez alone for those 3 guys :)
User avatar
jsence2
Reactions:
Posts: 18758
Joined: Tue Dec 16, 2008 10:57 pm
Location: Louisville, KY

Re: Trade Thread

Post by jsence2 »

Is there gonna be any discussion/post on the Buster Posey trade? :|
Image

S14: N Texas 7-1
S15: Wake 8-5
S16-21: Washington 9-4, 10-3, 8-5, 9-4, 7-6, 6-7
S22: Ohio 8-5
S23: ECU 12-2
S24-26: Kentucky 8-5, 5-7, 5-7
Career: 102-61
User avatar
ReignOnU
Reactions:
Posts: 19643
Joined: Sat Feb 07, 2009 12:18 pm
Location: Cincinnati Titans
Contact:

Re: Trade Thread

Post by ReignOnU »

Which teams?
PSN: ReignOnU
User avatar
ReignOnU
Reactions:
Posts: 19643
Joined: Sat Feb 07, 2009 12:18 pm
Location: Cincinnati Titans
Contact:

Re: Trade Thread

Post by ReignOnU »

It didn't go through. I'm guessing Niddler / Ryan were experimenting or Ryan just nixed it.
PSN: ReignOnU
The_Niddler
Reactions:
Posts: 17229
Joined: Thu Jan 21, 2010 6:57 pm
Location: Small Town, Ohio

Re: Trade Thread

Post by The_Niddler »

Yeah, that was me playing around. I asked Ryan to deny it immediately.
I told him, I wish the game had a way of just seeing if it would be accepted before it actually being accepted.

And I also wish that the trades that were denied, would show as denied instead of as accepted.
If you look at the players, they are all still on their original teams.

I know I will have to give up much more to get Posey.
PSN: The_Niddler
TWITCH: The_Niddler
User avatar
ReignOnU
Reactions:
Posts: 19643
Joined: Sat Feb 07, 2009 12:18 pm
Location: Cincinnati Titans
Contact:

Re: Trade Thread

Post by ReignOnU »

You can get a pretty good idea of how good the trade is if you go to the website and put it in there. The meter shows you how favorable it is for each side. While it's not perfect, it's better for figuring that out than the console is.
PSN: ReignOnU
User avatar
jsence2
Reactions:
Posts: 18758
Joined: Tue Dec 16, 2008 10:57 pm
Location: Louisville, KY

Re: Trade Thread

Post by jsence2 »

The_Niddler wrote:Yeah, that was me playing around. I asked Ryan to deny it immediately.
I told him, I wish the game had a way of just seeing if it would be accepted before it actually being accepted.

And I also wish that the trades that were denied, would show as denied instead of as accepted.
If you look at the players, they are all still on their original teams.

I know I will have to give up much more to get Posey.

Gotcha. I saw it last night in game and then today as "completed" and was like "um....." :lol:
Image

S14: N Texas 7-1
S15: Wake 8-5
S16-21: Washington 9-4, 10-3, 8-5, 9-4, 7-6, 6-7
S22: Ohio 8-5
S23: ECU 12-2
S24-26: Kentucky 8-5, 5-7, 5-7
Career: 102-61
The_Niddler
Reactions:
Posts: 17229
Joined: Thu Jan 21, 2010 6:57 pm
Location: Small Town, Ohio

Re: Trade Thread

Post by The_Niddler »

ReignOnU wrote:You can get a pretty good idea of how good the trade is if you go to the website and put it in there. The meter shows you how favorable it is for each side. While it's not perfect, it's better for figuring that out than the console is.
Yeah, the meter, it exists on the console, but even if it shows as even, sometimes the other team says it is unfair.
PSN: The_Niddler
TWITCH: The_Niddler
User avatar
ReignOnU
Reactions:
Posts: 19643
Joined: Sat Feb 07, 2009 12:18 pm
Location: Cincinnati Titans
Contact:

Re: Trade Thread

Post by ReignOnU »

Right... the meter online shows you how far favorable you are to your team. I don't think the meter on the console does.
PSN: ReignOnU
User avatar
I_S33M_THAB33T_U
Reactions:
Posts: 4848
Joined: Tue Sep 15, 2009 1:28 am
Contact:

Re: Trade Thread

Post by I_S33M_THAB33T_U »

jsence2 wrote:Is there gonna be any discussion/post on the Buster Posey trade? :|

You mean the one that got denied within 4 mins. ;)
User avatar
jsence2
Reactions:
Posts: 18758
Joined: Tue Dec 16, 2008 10:57 pm
Location: Louisville, KY

Re: Trade Thread

Post by jsence2 »

I_S33M_THAB33T_U wrote:
jsence2 wrote:Is there gonna be any discussion/post on the Buster Posey trade? :|

You mean the one that got denied within 4 mins. ;)

Again, it showed on the site as 'completed", thus why I asked.
Image

S14: N Texas 7-1
S15: Wake 8-5
S16-21: Washington 9-4, 10-3, 8-5, 9-4, 7-6, 6-7
S22: Ohio 8-5
S23: ECU 12-2
S24-26: Kentucky 8-5, 5-7, 5-7
Career: 102-61
Post Reply

Return to “Ryan's Fantasy Franchise”